Mama’s Fish house is without question one of the best restaurants on Maui, possibly the country. Even if you don’t like seafood (which you won’t find any better than the fresh fish from Mama’s), you’ll love the food, ambiance and experience you’ll get from dining at Maui’s best seafood restaurant! Even if the cost to dine and eat here might be more than you’d want to spend on the average meal, it’s completely worth the cost of eating here. You won’t regret it, whether it’s evening or the daytime, whether you get a seafood entree or just their appetizers and soup or drinks. But one caution, reservations can be booked up months in advance, so if you want to experience the best seafood in Maui, make sure to book a reservation as soon as you know you’re going to be on Maui.
no images were found
Northern Maui; Paia
Parking Lot; Valet Parking
Location799 Poho Place
Paia HI 96779
Creatively prepared local seafood is accompanied by creative sauces & local, organic produce.
DescriptionCreatively prepared local seafood is accompanied by creative sauces & local, organic produce.
Related and Nearby
Paia Fish Market
Best dining experience ever
Cost; however, it’s completely worth it.
Need a Mama’s Fish House Reservation? Maybe we can help!
Want to try some of the other best seafood restaurants on Maui? Check this out!
Mama’s Fish House Review Maui
Mama’s Fish House is an iconic restaurant on Maui and a destination for food lovers around the world. It’s renowned not just for its beautiful setting and view of the ocean, but also for its excellent seafood dishes.
I had the pleasure of dining there recently, and here’s my review of Mama’s Fish House in Maui.
The atmosphere at Mama’s Fish House was nothing short of spectacular. The outdoor seating area offers breathtaking views of the beach and sea, making it easy to see why this place has become so popular with locals and tourists alike.
Inside, the decor is traditional Hawaiian-style, with plenty of vibrant colors that help create a cozy yet sophisticated ambiance.
Location And Atmosphere
Mama’s Fish House in Maui is located in a lush, tropical paradise, with plenty of palm trees and lush vegetation surrounding the restaurant.
The view of the ocean is breathtaking, with a wonderful terrace to enjoy while you dine.
Inside, the atmosphere is laid-back and relaxed, making it the perfect spot for a romantic evening or a family meal.
The décor is tasteful and inviting, with plenty of natural light streaming in from the windows and terrace.
Music is usually playing softly in the background, creating a peaceful atmosphere.
All in all, Mama’s Fish House is a beautiful spot to enjoy a delicious meal in a relaxed and romantic atmosphere.
Stepping onto the grounds of Mama’s Fish House is an experience in and of itself. One can’t help but be awed by its lush landscaping, with tropical flowers, exotic birds, and vibrant colors all around – it certainly sets a romantic mood for sunsets!
The friendly staff makes sure to keep everything well-maintained, making sure that every plant remains healthy and every leaf looks just perfect. This contributes to the relaxing ambience; one could easily spend hours just admiring the beauty of nature here.
It truly speaks volumes about the warm hospitality offered at this restaurant; no detail has been left untouched when it comes to providing guests with a memorable atmosphere. All in all, Mama’s Fish House succeeds in creating a tranquil oasis where visitors can kick back and enjoy some exquisite cuisine.
The stunning ocean view from Mama’s Fish House is unmatched, with the waves providing an ever-changing backdrop that adds to its island ambience.
The restaurant has managed to capture both a romantic setting and sustainable practices in one place – something customers have been raving about!
You can feel the ocean breezes on your skin as you indulge in traditional Hawaiian flavors.
Listen closely for wave sounds that will transport you away into another world of cultural influences.
With so many unique elements at play, it’s no surprise that guests are drawn back here time after time.
The relaxed ambiance of Mama’s Fish House is definitely a major part of the appeal. From the beachside dining to the tropical decor, you can’t help but feel at ease as soon as you walk in.
The relaxing music and friendly staff make it family-friendly and inviting for all ages.
They offer signature dishes with unique flavors that capture the island vibes perfectly. Plus, their menu changes frequently so there are always new dishes to discover!
Whether you’re looking to relax or try something new, Mama’s Fish House has something special for everyone.
Menu And Prices
Mama’s Fish House has some of the best seafood in Maui; they’ve got an impressive variety of it too.
The prices are a bit steep, but you’re paying for quality.
I definitely recommend the seafood, it’s definitely worth the cost.
The variety of dishes is incredible, there’s something for everyone.
Prices may be a bit high, but the quality and taste of the seafood make it worth it.
All in all, Mama’s Fish House is a great spot for seafood lovers.
The seafood menu at Mama’s Fish House Maui is an absolute treat. From sustainably sourced ocean-caught fish to local island flavors, the restaurant offers a unique variety of flavors that you won’t find anywhere else.
Every meal comes with fresh ingredients and is presented in a way that really highlights each dish’s unique flavor. The top notch chefs here make sure that every plate looks like a work of art – full of vibrant colors and delicious aromas.
I’m always delighted by how well the team combines local cuisine with signature island spices for a truly one-of-a-kind experience. All in all, Mama’s Fish House Maui has something special for everyone who loves seafood!
The prices at Mama’s Fish House Maui are surprisingly reasonable given the quality of their seafood selection. The portion sizes are generous, and you can easily get multiple dishes to share. Even better, when compared to other restaurants in the area, it’s definitely one of the best values around! Plus, there aren’t any hidden fees or surprise charges – so what you see is what you pay.
One thing I really appreciate about this restaurant is its reservation system: no more waiting in line with a large group hoping for a table! You can book private events as well, making it perfect for special occasions like anniversaries and birthdays.
Not to mention that the atmosphere here makes it great for an intimate dinner out with your significant other.
All in all, Mama’s Fish House Maui offers top-notch cuisine at an affordable price point that won’t break your budget. With its charming ambiance and delicious food, it’s sure to be an unforgettable dining experience each time you visit!
When it comes to variety, Mama’s Fish House Maui really has something for everyone. From unique flavors and sustainable sourcing of their seafood dishes to multiple ambiance choices and seating arrangements, you can customize your experience in many different ways.
Plus there’s a great selection of portion sizes so that you don’t have to worry about over- or under-ordering! And depending on the time of day, they offer up some amazing special events like happy hour specials or dessert varieties.
It’s no wonder this place is always abuzz with activity – from private parties to intimate dinners out, Mama’s Fish House Maui offers an unforgettable dining experience every time!
The catch of the day at Mama’s Fish House in Maui was nothing short of spectacular – the freshest seafood I’ve ever tasted!
Not only did it taste amazing, but I was glad to know it was sustainably caught too.
The restaurant clearly takes the time to source their ingredients responsibly.
I’d definitely recommend Mama’s Fish House to anyone looking for a delicious seafood dinner that’s both delicious and guilt-free!
Catch Of The Day
Heading to Mama’s Fish House on Maui means you’re in for a seafood treat like no other.
The Catch of the Day is an excellent representation of sustainable sourcing, local knowledge and fishing techniques that have been passed down through generations.
From fresh-caught Ahi tuna to succulent mahi-mahi, it’s all about freshness here and each fish has its own unique flavor thanks to the careful preparation by the expert chefs.
The menu also offers up some more exotic flavors such as Onaga, Kajiki and Opah caught using traditional Hawaiian conservation methods which are both respectful of oceanic ecology while ensuring plentiful catches year after year.
It’s not just about what type of fish is served at Mama’s Fish House but how it gets there – with plenty of respect paid to nature along the way.
Each dish showcases the natural beauty of these island waters and is presented with care and attention to detail so diners can enjoy a feast without feeling guilty or overwhelmed by too many choices.
With creative sides such as grilled pineapple salsa, creamy macaroni salad and taro chips made from locally grown ingredients, this restaurant ensures every palate is catered for.
From start to finish, Mama’s Fish House delivers delicious dishes that represent much more than simply tasty food – they capture a sense of place, culture and tradition that will leave customers wanting more!
As I finish my meal at Mama’s Fish House, it is clear to me why this restaurant has become a Maui staple.
Not only are their dishes unbelievably delicious and packed with flavor from the local ingredients, but they have also taken great measures to ensure sustainable fishing practices that support ocean conservation.
Through locally sourcing their seafood and utilizing traditional Hawaiian fishing techniques, the team here ensures each Catch of the Day is both safe for consumption and respectful of our precious ecosystems.
They even use green initiatives such as sustainable agriculture and native ingredients in other dishes on their menu!
It’s no wonder people flock to Mama’s Fish House for an unforgettable experience – one that celebrates sustainability while tantalizing taste buds.
Specialty Hawaiian Dishes
Mama’s Fish House in Maui serves some of the best specialty Hawaiian dishes I’ve ever tried! The poi was especially delicious, and I was also impressed with the laulau and kalua pig.
The poke and lau lau were so flavorful, as well as the huli huli chicken, lomi lomi salmon, squid luau, pipikaula, ox tail soup, ahi katsu, kalbi ribs, haupia, opihi, and haupia pie.
Poi is a staple Hawaiian dish, and Mama’s Fish House does it justice. The poi here is sourced locally and sustainably, giving you that authentic taste of the islands.
For those looking for vegan alternatives, they have those too! Plus, with takeout options available, you can enjoy your meal at home or on the beach in no time.
Not to mention their live music nights and happy hour specials make this spot even more attractive. Private dining is also an option if you’re wanting to host a special event – all that plus close access to the beach makes Mama’s Fish House perfect for any occasion!
The next specialty Hawaiian dish I want to discuss is laulau, and it’s a must-try at Mama’s Fish House.
This traditional preparation of pork or fish wrapped in taro leaves creates unique flavors that are truly special – they’ve been perfected over generations thanks to family recipes!
Plus, with local ingredients used throughout the year, you can enjoy seasonal availability too.
And when it comes to sauces and condiments, this spot has got it down pat; their cultural influences really come through here.
No matter your preference, there’s something for everyone on the menu – from takeout options to private dining experiences – making Mama’s Fish House an ideal setting for any occasion.
Cocktails And Drinks
I was impressed with Mama’s Fish House’s cocktail menu, with a selection of creative and unique tiki drinks.
Their wine list was also impressive, featuring a variety of labels from all over the world.
The signature drinks, however, were my favorite – the Mai Tai was a great balance of sweet and sour and the Blue Hawaii was both visually stunning and delicious.
All in all, Mama’s Fish House in Maui did not disappoint in the cocktails and drinks department.
I highly recommend it for anyone looking to try something special.
As soon as I stepped into Mama’s Fish House in Maui, I was struck by its unique cocktail list.
Every drink contained exotic flavors and tropical ingredients that added a special touch to the experience.
Rum based drinks were particularly popular- with happy hour specials on offer every day!
There were also mocktail options for those who don’t partake in alcohol- perfect for family gatherings or brunch dates.
The cocktails were custom creations, made from sustainable sourced ingredients, combined with artisanal recipes.
From beginning to end it felt like a true taste of paradise – an amazing escape right here at home!
The wine list was also something to be admired, with a great selection of local wines from the islands.
The tasting notes were well-described and gave insight into each vintage’s flavor profile – perfect for any keen connoisseur.
There were plenty of seafood pairings on offer as well, making it easy to find that ideal pairing!
For those who bring their own bottle, there is no corkage fee or BYOB policy – so you can enjoy your favorite vino without worry.
Overall, Mama’s Fish House had a comprehensive collection of drinks to choose from – an impressive array of cocktails and wines sure to please any palate.
The signature drinks at Mama’s Fish House did not disappoint. The spicy margaritas were a great way to start off the evening, and I could tell by the look on my friend’s face that they really hit the spot!
Not only that, but their mai tais were delightful too – perfectly balanced with just enough sweetness. Even those who don’t indulge in alcohol had plenty of options between the craft beer selection, tropical smoothies, rum punches and mocktails.
And for those looking for something more creative, there was a wide variety of specialty cocktails designed to tantalize your taste buds. From fruity concoctions to classic martinis, it seemed like there was something for everyone.
Overall, you can’t go wrong with any drink choice here – no matter what you’re craving!
Vegetarian And Gluten-Free Options
Mama’s Fish House in Maui offers an impressive array of vegetarian options, including a delicious roasted eggplant and a vegetable-filled stir-fry.
For those with gluten-related dietary restrictions, they also have some tasty offerings like a gluten-free coconut shrimp dish.
All in all, it’s a great place for diners with special diets to find something tasty.
All the flavors and textures work together to create a truly mouth-watering experience!
Mama’s Fish House in Maui offers a wide selection of vegetarian and gluten-free options that are sure to please.
From plant-based dishes to dairy free options, there is something for everyone!
The vegan desserts here are delicious and the bread choices offer great variety.
I especially enjoyed the vegetable sides which were cooked perfectly with just the right amount of flavor.
Tofu entrees, mock meats and gluten free breads round out this restaurant’s offerings for vegetarians who need or want more than salads.
No matter what your dietary needs may be, Mama’s Fish House has you covered!
All in all it was an enjoyable experience that left me feeling satisfied but not overly full – definitely worth checking out if you’re ever in Maui.
For those with dietary restrictions due to gluten allergies, Mama’s Fish House has you covered. The restaurant offers an array of dishes that are not only vegan but also gluten-free, from breads and desserts to entrees and sides.
With careful label reading and ingredient swaps, diners can customize their meal ideas for a delicious dining experience without sacrificing flavor or health benefits. There are plenty of avoidance strategies available here as well as recipes tailored specifically to meet the needs of individuals with gluten sensitivities.
All in all, this is one place I highly recommend if you’re looking for tasty gluten-free options!
The kid-friendly menu at Mama’s Fish House in Maui is top-notch, with plenty of options that even picky eaters will enjoy. The atmosphere is warm and inviting, making the entire family feel right at home.
Additionally, the staff is incredibly attentive to the needs of kids, offering plenty of child-friendly activities to keep them busy while parents dine. Out on the patio, I spotted kids playing hula hoop, kicking around a soccer ball, and even trying out a few ukulele chords.
In short, Mama’s Fish House is an ideal spot for a family meal.
Mama’s Fish House is a great spot for the whole family to have dinner. I’ve been there with my kids and they absolutely love it!
The atmosphere is super family-friendly, and you can customize your meals however you like. Plus, the staff are really friendly and helpful when it comes to catering for families. You can also be sure that all the ingredients used in their dishes are locally sourced, so you know you’re getting high quality food.
They offer some delicious specialty desserts too, which my little ones always get excited about trying out! And if you find yourself running short of time, Mama’s Fish House also offers takeout options so you don’t miss out on their amazing treats.
To keep children entertained while dining in, they provide complimentary activities to ensure everyone has a good time during the meal.
Overall, Mama’s Fish House is an ideal place for families looking for good food and fun times together. With its kid-friendly menu and activities plus customized meals made from locally sourced produce – what more could you ask for?
Even better: no need to wrap up early as there are plenty of takeout options available too! What a treat this restaurant provides; definitely one worth checking out!
At Mama’s Fish House, you can expect a truly family-friendly atmosphere.
From the Hawaiian culture that greets guests upon arrival to the ocean views from their outdoor seating area, this eatery is perfect for those looking for an immersive dining experience.
Not only do they provide healthy options with amazing seafood quality but also offer excellent customer service and high standards of service.
Reviews often mention how enjoyable the atmosphere is and rate it highly – no wonder so many families enjoy eating there!
There’s something for everyone here; kids will love exploring their creative activities while adults get to indulge in some well-deserved relaxation time.
An evening at Mama’s Fish House promises to be one filled with good food, great fun, and lasting memories – what more could you ask for?
At Mama’s Fish House, there are lots of kid-friendly activities to choose from. For beach trips, they offer snorkeling tours and whale watching excursions – perfect for a family outing.
If you’re feeling adventurous, then try out their sunset cruise or take the kids swimming in their pool! Their cultural tours will give your children an insight into Hawaiian culture, while outdoor games like hula hooping and volleyball can keep them entertained for hours on end.
And don’t forget to get some fun family photos taken too! There’s no doubt that everyone at Mama’s Fish House will have had an amazing day together – this is truly one place where memories are made!
Professional And Courteous Service
I was pleasantly surprised by the professional yet courteous service I received at Mama’s Fish House in Maui.
From the moment I entered the restaurant, I was greeted with a warm welcome and given timely and helpful advice on the menu.
The wait staff was attentive and knowledgeable, going above and beyond to make sure we were happy with our dining experience.
I’d definitely recommend Mama’s Fish House to anyone looking for a top-notch, professional and courteous service.
When it comes to dining in Maui, the professional and courteous service at Mama’s Fish House is second to none. From the friendly staff that greeted me with a warm smile upon arrival, to the high quality of table service throughout my meal – I felt like royalty!
The menu selection was excellent too; from various seafood options, to traditional Hawaiian dishes – there was something for everyone. Not only were each dish beautifully presented on their plate, but the ambiance setting was simply breathtaking – making this an unforgettable experience!
It’s no wonder why Mama’s Fish House has earned its reputation as one of the best restaurants in town.
The friendly staff at Mama’s Fish House made me feel welcomed from the moment I stepped in. They were attentive to my needs and even went out of their way to accommodate any special requests that I had.
The service quality was top-notch as well; they responded quickly, delivered food on time and provided extra attention throughout my meal.
All these factors really elevated my overall experience, making it a truly memorable one! Needless to say, between the generous menu options, outstanding table service and courteous staff – Mama’s Fish House is without a doubt one of Maui’s finest restaurants.
Outdoor Seating With An Ocean View
The breathtaking views of the Pacific Ocean while dining at Mama’s Fish House in Maui was simply divine! The relaxing ambience of the lovely outdoor seating area was the perfect way to enjoy a meal.
The fresh seafood was absolutely delicious and cooked to perfection. I could hardly take my eyes off the ocean as I enjoyed every bite.
The outdoor seating area was the perfect place to unwind and take in the beauty of my surroundings. I would highly recommend Mama’s Fish House for outdoor seating with an ocean view!
Seated at the outdoor patio of Mama’s Fish House, one can immediately be struck by the breathtaking sunset views while surrounded by tropical vibes.
The restaurant features a variety of options for seafood and land-loving diners alike, from surf and turf to vegan delights.
You won’t want to miss out on their luau favorites either – I highly recommend trying the local catch!
Beach cocktails are also available as well, making this spot perfect for a family friendly night out.
Enjoying all that Maui has to offer has never been easier or more picturesque!
The relaxing vibes of Mama’s Fish House are unparalleled.
From the romantic setting to the soundscape music, it makes for a perfect evening out.
The outdoor seating is comfortable and well-maintained with friendly staff ready to take your orders or customize them as needed.
Not only do they serve up amazing island flavors, but food presentation here is really something special too.
With all these elements combined you can easily get lost in this tropical haven – an unforgettable experience!
The seafood selection at Mama’s Fish House is impressive. With its commitment to sustainable sourcing, you can be sure that every dish will be of the highest quality and packed with plenty of regional flavors.
The portion sizes are generous, so you won’t have to worry about leaving hungry! Plus, they offer a range of tapas options for those who want to sample multiple dishes during their visit.
As if that wasn’t enough, each plate is infused with an array of Hawaiian spices that adds another layer of flavor to your meal. And don’t forget about the friendly staff – always happy to help out when it comes to customizing orders or recommending dishes.
All in all, diners here can look forward to a fresh seafood experience like no other.
A Delicious Experience To Remember
The food at Mama’s Fish House in Maui was simply exquisite. The chefs used a creative mix of ingredients that had me savoring every bite.
The service was top notch, with staff being attentive and friendly.
The atmosphere was romantic and tranquil, with the beautiful beachfront view adding to the ambiance.
I was truly impressed by the attention to detail they had in every aspect of the dining experience.
I highly recommend Mama’s Fish House in Maui for a delicious experience to remember!
At Mama’s Fish House, the food is a delicious experience to remember. The quality of the ingredients sourced locally and organically make for bold flavors that will tantalize your taste buds.
Every dish has been carefully crafted with sustainable fishing in mind and presented creatively. You can choose from a diverse range of flavors, including vegan options if you prefer. Custom orders are also available if you’re looking for something special!
Overall, Mama’s Fish House offers an unforgettable meal with its unique combination of fresh local produce and organic ingredients creating memorable dishes bursting with flavor. An ocean-side treat with plenty of delight awaits all who visit this Maui eatery!
The service at Mama’s Fish House is exemplary and has earned them glowing reviews from customers. Specialty services such as custom orders, complimentary amenities like ocean-side seating, friendly staff, prompt delivery and spacious seating are all part of their vast offering.
Customers have nothing but positive feedback for the level of customer care they receive here – it’s no wonder why this Maui eatery continues to get rave reviews!
The delicious cuisine served here is always presented in creative ways that tantalize taste buds with bold flavors made possible by local organic ingredients.
From start to finish, visitors can expect a truly unique dining experience full of delight!
Ambiance And Atmosphere
The ambiance and atmosphere of Mama’s Fish House is akin to a luxury getaway.
From the moment you arrive, you can feel the relaxed vibes emanating from its colorful decor and tropical ambiance.
It has an intimate setting that creates a romantic setting perfect for couples or other special occasions.
Its unique decor featuring local artwork adds to the luxurious feel making it one of Maui’s premier dining destinations.
Whether looking for a peaceful dinner by the ocean or just wanting to soak up some stunning views with friends, this spot offers something truly memorable!
Frequently Asked Questions
Are Reservations Required?
When it comes to a restaurant like Mama’s Fish House, reservations are definitely required!
After all, everyone loves the menu options, spectacular view rating and parking availability.
But don’t even think about trying to just show up without making prior arrangements – this top-notch cuisine type eatery is in high demand for its seating capacity.
Even if you do manage to snag a table without booking first, the payment options will be limited and customer service might not be quite as friendly either.
And that simply won’t do when you’re talking about such an atmosphere rating gem!
What Are The Hours Of Operation?
Mama’s Fish House is open for dinner from 5pm to 10pm and lunch hours of 11:30am to 2:30pm.
The menu selection offers a diverse array of seafood dishes ranging from traditional favorites like fish tacos, ceviche, as well as unique options such as the Lobster Coconut Curry.
For those wanting convenience, online ordering is available with quick delivery around Maui. There’s even parking availability on site and payment methods that include major credit cards or gift certificates.
If you are looking for some live music while dining, Mama’s Fish House has special events every Friday night featuring local artists playing Hawaiian classics.
And don’t forget about their loyalty program which will give you discounts on food specials when you join!
Is There A Dress Code?
Mama’s Fish House is known for its special occasions and dressy attire, although a formal dress code isn’t enforced.
Regardless of age or pet policy considerations, you’ll be sure to find something suitable in the parking lot when visiting this restaurant.
Payment methods vary, but pricing ranges from moderate to pricey depending on your menu choices.
All-in-all, Mama’s Fish House provides an enjoyable experience worth dressing up for!
Is There A Take-Out Option?
Mama’s Fish House offers a great take-out menu that allows you to enjoy their delicious food right in the comfort of your own home.
The restaurant provides several options for ordering, such as online ordering and call-in orders, as well as delivery service. Customers can also choose to pick up their order or utilize their drive thru service with convenient pickup times.
Payment methods are just as easy – customers may use cash or credit cards. If you’re short on time, curbside pickup is available too!
Is There A Private Event Space Available?
Mama’s Fish House is a great spot for private events, offering free parking, outdoor seating and kid-friendly options.
The restaurant also has limited seating, so it’s best to book ahead if you can.
Vegetarian options are available alongside the local seafood specialties, perfect for large groups with mixed dietary preferences.
You’ll find plenty of parking in the lot and payment methods include cash and credit cards.
All in all, Mama’s Fish House offers an ideal setting for any kind of function or special occasion!
I can say with absolute certainty that Mama’s Fish House is a great place to visit while in Maui.
The atmosphere was warm and inviting, the food was delicious, and the staff were friendly and attentive.
I especially enjoyed the views of the beach from my table – it felt like paradise!
If you’re looking for an unforgettable dining experience in Maui, then Mama’s Fish House should be your go-to spot.
Whether you come for dinner or just have drinks at their bar, you won’t regret it!
Restaurant Name: Mama's Fish House
Restaurant Description: Our Favorite Restaurant and Will Probably be Yours Too!
You can't go wrong at Mama's Fish House! Mama's Fish House gets the top spot, without question in our minds.
If you've been to Mama's Fish House before, you know that you will get treated like royalty. There have been people working here for twenty years, so chances are if you've been here before or if you come back, you'll recognize some of the staff. Just about every staff member greets you with a smile, whether that are directly involved in your meal or not.
The waiting staff are very attentive, waters are always full and you're treated to all sorts of extras, such as housemade bread, a complementary soup sampler while you're waiting for your entree, a special treat if you notify them of any special occasions and, at the end of it all, you'll receive a farewell coconut haupia dessert along with a hot scented towel to clean your hands off.
Summed up: Impeccable service.
Beautifully designed, Mama's Fish House makes you feel as if you're in the heart of a Hawaiian palace. During the day, you'll get views of ocean and possibly the windsurfers and kiteboarders honing their craft on the water. If you come for dinner, you'll get to look out on the stars through the ambient light of the tiki torches lit out on the beach and the just-dim-enough lighting to complement a romantic evening.
Most come to Mama's Fish House to experience some of the freshest seafood Maui has to offer. On their menus which are printed daily are the names of the fishermen who caught the day's catch. Every day, new menus are printed with the updated catch.
There's an array of delicious both-seafood-based and other Hawaiian pupus or appetizers available for order. Whatever you end up choosing, however, you'll be happy with. One of our favorites is the Beef Polynesian, which isn't always labeled as such on the menus, however they always seem to offer it under one name or another. The Beef Polynesian is a stir-fry of beef served inside a fresh, local papaya with various other locally grown produce. They give you a lime to squeeze over it, which adds a slight citrus-y taste and the sweet from the papaya complements the sour from the lime and the savory from the beef.
While Mama's Fish House does offer non-seafood entree options, your best bet is something along the lines of seafood. You won't find fresher seafood anywhere other than on the end of your own fishing pole. You won't get better preparation anywhere, either.
One of our favorites is the curry.
Again, you can't go wrong picking any of the dessert options. They have a lilikoi (passion fruit) creme brulee and homemade ice cream. Our favorite, however, is the beautifully prepared Polynesian Black Pearl, which is a chocolate-covered chocolate mousse, served inside a housemade pasty clam shell and drizzled with a sweet lilikoi syrup. Possibly the perfect ending to an incredible meal.
Mama's does not skimp on presentation for anything. Whether its the food, the table, the wait staff; everything is planned, trimmed and picked down to the tiniest detail.
You won't find fresher fish anywhere on island in a restaurant and Mama's even tells you the names of the fishermen who caught the fish in their daily printed menu.
This is the only fault at all we can find with Mama's Fish House. Everything here tends to be pretty expensive. It's not uncommon for drinks to cost around $20 each and it adds up quick. That being said, you pay for what you get and eating at Mama's Fish House is totally worth it.
- Overall Experience
You may have noticed that despite the Cost rating receiving a 2/5 stars, that the overall rating is still a 5/5 stars. That's because we modified our system this one time to give the Overall Experience rating an 8/5 stars! Mama's is so good that, despite the high cost, everything is still just about perfect. You will love Mama's Fish House, even if your wallet is a little light afterwards. Just make sure to book your reservation ahead of time, or you may miss your chance to eat here, as it books up months in advance.